“So that others won’t have to”

(other people’s children mentioned)

A while ago I went to the dentist for my hygenist appointment, and got into conversation with her.  It turns out that her son has a kind of disorder I’d never heard of – something about not being able to make oils, so his skin is extremely dry & prone to eczema.  He needs to be slathered in a perscription lotion, have baths infrequently, and make regular visits to the children’s hospital about an hour away.  It sounds pretty miserable all in all. 

My hygenist mentioned that when her son questions why he ended up with this disorder – and the other things that affect him – she tells him “you go through this so that others won’t have to.”

Now, let me make the disclaimer that I know we are all different; we all find different ways of making sense of the world and our own situations.  The above explanation appears to work for my hygenist and her family, and I don’t want to minimize that.  I want to say, however, that it really doesn’t work *at all* for me.

It’s too close to sentiments like “God only gives you what you can handle.  He knows your strength better than you do.”  In my view, God doesn’t dish out the pain, misery and tragedy in the world.  I think most of that is evidence that evil is at work in our world – sometimes in an individual, often because of the overall sum of how humankind works.  For example, I think alot of infertility could be traced back to pollution issues, pesticides, etc.  I do think that sheer random back luck happens.  I suppose God sometimes does send us trials, but I just can’t imagine a loving God planning and sending the most terrible experiences that some of us undergo. 

Much of my thinking for this comes from the book “When Bad Things Happen to Good People.”  That book was critical in the search for my own faith.  If I accepted the view that God is loving – which is what I felt to be true – how could I understand all the terrible things that happen in this world?  This battle with evil, affecting all of us, was part of my answer.  As I studied science, it was also important to me that these answers made sense with what I knew of the world tried by experiment. Thus came the idea that God created the universe, and set the laws of physics etc. in motion, and put the power of self-determination in our hands.  The theory of evolution makes sense to me; I really have a hard time seeing why people find science & faith to be opposite sides of the divide.  The more I study science, the more it seems to me I see God’s signature in everything.  Watching cells under a microscope still takes my breath away. 

But God isn’t going to contravene the laws of physics to make miracles happen just because we pray for them.  That’s not to say I don’t believe miracles ever happen, but just to say that I don’t think God is like a gumball machine.  Enter the correct number of prayers, out rolls the desired answer.  It isn’t that simple.  We are in the world as it is, as it has come to us from countless ancestors, and future generations will inherit the results of our decisions.  We are caught in that current.  I can’t stop myself from praying for miracles for those I love, and for myself too, but I also put faith in the decisions made by others that will bring light, love and hope into this world.  I sure pray for the scientists working on ways to help those with infertility, asthma, allergies, and many other things.  Perhaps the Spirit will give them a flash of inspiration that will lead to a great discovery – within the laws of the universe.  (and I do think prayer is very important, but more because it develops our relationship with God, than for deal-making.  Of course, I can’t deny I’ve tried making deals at times too.)

I also believe that no matter how grim the situation we are in, if we can offer it to God and come to Him(Her), it can be made better.  We can get through it more easily with His support – we can find peace.  He is with us in all of the most terrible times.  I believe He sheds tears with us, holds us when we are sobbing, and guides us towards the peace, hope and strength to go on.

If someone seriously told me that the struggles that we have are ours so that others wouldn’t have to deal with them – well, I’m afraid I’d return a pretty uncharitable response.  I did not choose to have these struggles.  It is not fair that we have them – it is not fair that others struggle with their health issues, watch their children starve, or suffer war crimes.  Instead of bringing me comfort, this kind of statment makes me angry and resentful.  How do you react to this explanation for the question of WHY?  Do you have a different answer?

What is my answer? I suppose, part of it is the wide-spread and often random effects of evil, and the randomness in nature too.  Maybe exposure to pollution, mass food production, and very different challenges to the immune system than what we used to have.  I guess we all have to find our own answers.  And anyway, I think the really important question is how do we move on, how do we cope?  For me, prayer and asking for help in the struggle is part of the answer.  Others perhaps find their way in advocacy, fund-raising, supporting other people.  All of these are life-giving ways to take a personal tragedy and help others and ourselves. 

I volunteered for about a year with a shelter for street youth.  Some of them were refugees from other countries, some were home-grown Canadians.  Many of their stories would break your heart.  One boy in particular had been forced to be a child soldier, and faced all the horrors of war, his family & hometown and everything torn apart.  He had escaped to build a better life here.  His determination, courage and perhaps even desperation really struck me.  I think about him sometimes and hope he has found his way.

But I would never have told him that he went through those experiences so that I, or anyone else, would be spared from them.



6 thoughts on ““So that others won’t have to”

  1. Sam says:

    Gosh, no, no, that’s not right is it, to say “so that others wont have to” – that is so not what God means.

    There is a difference between knowing that God knows that we can cope with this and thinking that we are going through this just so someone else wont have to.

    I want to say more along these lines, but my thoughts are all in a tangle at the moment as I try to say what I mean!

  2. I love this post! This is something I struggle with all the time….I can’t tell you how many times I’ve heard “He only gives you what you can handle” and I think, “really?”

    I am at a point in my faith right now where I am trying to figure out just how much God is responsible for what happens in this world…and I have to agree with you, that I don’t think we can blame him for all of the bad…but then it’s hard to reconcile crediting him for all of the good!

    We could have hours & hours of convo about this & it would be soooo interesting! 🙂

    Take care 🙂

  3. Amy says:

    I’ll go ahead and minimize it–

    I would have been severely tempted to say, “Lady, you don’t tell your kid who–let’s face it, suffers from something you or I probably can’t even imagine–that it’s his role in life to serve as some sort of sacrificial entity.

    I wouldn’t have said it, but I would have had to bite my tongue not to.

    The sheer inaccuracy of her statement aside, she’s just adding to the load he’s already carrying.

    I understand that she’s probably trying to instill some sense of heroism in him so that he doesn’t grow up focusing on the injustice of it all, but that explanation horrifies me. It really does. She’s negating any justified emotion he has over this.

    It IS unfair, dammit. And he should get to feel that way.

    (stepping down from the soapbox)

  4. jaded me says:

    i have been struggling with this issue, i too do NOT beleive that God hands out evil and suffering. Trials, yes. i have been struggling with so much shit lately – the loss of my two pregnancies at 22 and 23 wks gestation, my crappy job which i may lose at any minute, and the knowledge that my future pregnancies may also be just as complicated. i feel like i have to fight for every good thing in my life. i want to turn to God and give him my worries, but when i did so (to save my babies) he didn’t. is he bad for this, i dont’ think so, but now i struggle with prayer. for what? i think, he is goign to do what needs to be done, so why bother i think?

  5. thalia says:

    I imagine the little boy might have ichthyosis like soper’s daughter? (blogs at uterine wars)

  6. Hi, I’m Miryam. These are my kids. We’ll be your lightning rod for today. Please stand by, while we wait for thunder.

    Um, no.

    When my pediatrician jokes that we fill a lot of quotas for her practice, I grin with her. We do, but we don’t do it from a martyred sense of preserving the other kids in the practice. Altruism can’t be falsely layered over simple chance, or even divine plan: if this was given to us, then it is ours. Not ours for the sake of others, just ours. And if others benefit by watching us face challenges, or by helping, then hooray.

    But it’s still just ours.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s